Halloween wouldn’t be quite the same without orange candy corn, red gummies, and lollipops that turn your tongue blue. But lately, those familiar colors have been getting a little extra attention as brands change the ingredients behind them. So what’s changing, and what does it mean for your candy bowl? Let’s take a closer look at food dyes, why companies are rethinking them, and how to choose treats that fit your preferences. There’s more to the story than scary headlines.
What are food dyes?
Food dyes add color, keep it consistent, or help foods look the way we expect. They can also hint at a flavor, like yellow for lemon. Some are synthetic, including Red 40, Yellow 5, and Blue 1. Others come from sources like beets, annatto, or grape skins. Both types are color additives, and the FDA reviews them for their intended uses in food. [1, 2]
Color can make food more appealing, but it doesn’t tell us how nutritious it is. That’s true whether a gummy gets its bright red color from a synthetic dye or beet extract.
Why did food dyes become a hot topic?
Food dyes aren’t new, but they’ve become part of a bigger conversation about what goes into the foods we buy. Many shoppers want more recognizable ingredients, and brands are paying attention. At the same time, regulators are encouraging companies to move toward colors from natural sources. Together, these shifts have brought food dyes into the spotlight. [4, 5]
Part of the confusion comes from the headlines about Red No. 3, which is a different dye from Red 40. It’s easy for news about one to sound like it applies to every red coloring, even though they’re separate ingredients. [3]
Why are companies changing their recipes?
For many brands, it’s about keeping up with what shoppers want while responding to regulatory attention. More recognizable ingredients and colors from natural sources are part of that shift [4, 5]. A March 2026 Consumer Reports survey found that 72% of adults are at least somewhat concerned about synthetic dyes in food while 66% believe companies should have to phase them out [6].
That doesn’t mean every dye has been deemed dangerous. A recipe change can also reflect a company’s decision to offer something that better matches its customers’ preferences. General Mills, for example, announced in August 2026 that it had removed certified colors from all its U.S. cereals. It plans to complete the same change across its U.S. retail products by the end of 2027. [4]
Recipe changes take time, so you may see both old and new formulas on shelves. If you’re curious about what changed, compare the coloring ingredients on the packages. You might see synthetic dyes like Red 40 replaced with ingredients such as beet juice. The ingredient list on the package you’re buying will tell you which version you’re getting.
All Treats; No Tricks!
If you prefer colors from natural sources, look for ingredients such as beet juice, annatto, or fruit and vegetable extracts. Just keep in mind that “naturally colored” doesn’t automatically mean lower in sugar or more nutritious. It tells you where the color comes from, not what's in the recipe. The FDA said companies may use “no artificial colors” as long as the product has no petroleum-based dyes, even if it uses other approved colors.
Remember: candy is still candy! If you’re comparing treats, serving size and added sugars can help give you a fuller picture. But Halloween doesn’t need to become a trick vs. a treat. A few gummy bears or a piece of bright-orange candy corn can have a place in an overall balanced way of eating. Here is a quick guide to decoding grocery labels like a pro! →
Choose the candy you enjoy, look for different coloring ingredients if that matters to you, and leave room for the fun. The choices you make over time on a consistent basis matter more than the color of a single treat. This Halloween, enjoy the traditions, the colors, and your favorites. The colorful truth is a lot less scary than the headlines can make it sound.
Sources
- FDA. Color Additives in Foods.
- FDA. Color Additives Questions and Answers for Consumers.
- FDA. FD&C Red No. 3.
- General Mills. General Mills Completes Removal of Certified Colors from U.S. Cereal Portfolio. August 26, 2026.
- FDA. Tracking Food Industry Pledges to Remove Petroleum Based Food Dyes.
- March 2026 Consumer Reports.